The Pittsburgh Pirates are making waves this offseason, and their moves have sparked excitement and speculation. With a series of strategic trades and a notable free-agent signing, the Pirates are shaping up for an intriguing 2025-26 season. But here's where it gets controversial: the team's third base position is currently a cause for concern.
During the last trade deadline, the Pirates' general manager, Ben Cherington, made a bold move by dealing third baseman Ke'Bryan Hayes to the Reds. This left a significant gap in the roster, and now the Pirates are faced with a crucial decision: how to fill this critical infield position.
The Pirates' current options at third base are limited, with Jared Triolo being the most realistic choice. Triolo's performance last season, with an average of .227 over 331 at-bats, was decent but not enough to propel the team forward. The Pirates need a power-hitter to take them seriously, and Triolo alone won't cut it.
So, what's the solution?
Free Agency:
One intriguing option is Miguel Andújar, a player with the ability to also play left field. After a successful year with the Oakland Athletics and Cincinnati Reds, Andújar could be a valuable addition to the Pirates' lineup. His average of .318 over 321 at-bats and 10 home runs make him an attractive prospect.
Andújar's versatility and affordable contract (under $10 million next year) make him an appealing choice. He could platoon with Triolo and strengthen the left side of the infield. However, some may argue that Andújar is not the game-changer the Pirates need.
Other free agents like Ramón Urías and Isiah Kiner-Falefa could provide similar depth, but they might not be the long-term solution the Pirates are seeking.
Trade Options:
While a trade is less likely, the Pirates do have some valuable assets in their starting pitching rotation that could be used to acquire an everyday third baseman. Two players in particular have caught the eye: Isaac Paredes and Brendan Donovan.
Isaac Paredes:
Paredes is a young star, only 26 years old, and he brings power to the plate. With a 30-home run season under his belt, he could be the missing piece for the Pirates. However, acquiring Paredes would likely require the Pirates to part with a starting pitcher, a risky move that could impact their overall depth.
Brendan Donovan:
The St. Louis Cardinals are looking to rebuild their roster, and Donovan, a talented second baseman, could be on the move. His defensive skills and solid batting average (.287 with 32 doubles and 10 home runs last season) make him an attractive option. If the Pirates can secure Donovan, he could become their best hitter statistically.
The Pirates' decision at third base is a crucial one, and it will shape their performance for the upcoming season. Will they opt for a free agent like Andújar, or will they pursue a trade for a player like Paredes or Donovan?
And this is the part most people miss: the Pirates have the potential to surprise everyone and make a bold move. Will they take the safe route or go all-in for a potential game-changer?
What do you think? Should the Pirates focus on free agency or explore trade options? Let's discuss in the comments and share your thoughts on the Pirates' third base dilemma!
